Movie worries

**Aixoise** · Posted: Thu Jun 05, 2008 10:45 pm Post subject:

cowgirlkaty23 wrote:

edwardsmine wrote:

Yeah, I love that picture, too. Very Happy

Obviously! There are so many delicious ones to choose from though!

I'm curious to see, when I reread all the books, how Robert's face will fit into the pictures in my head! It will be weird to have a specific face in mind. I never really had a full picture of Edward in my head just pieces and more of a feeling of what he looked like...

It is so nice to have another person who feels exactly the same way I feel about Edward. I never had a perfectly clear picture in my head of Edward either, just like you said more of a feeling. I don't think I want RP floating in my head as Edward, I like my imagination better.

YESSSS!! I actually searched out this thread to ask the same exact thing!! Glad I'm not the only one. And I second the idea of leaving it to my imagination. Nothing against Rob but....seriously, who *could* match the perfection that is Edward?

_________________
Eternally Tohrmented.....and loving it

**pixievamp_08** · Posted: Fri Jun 06, 2008 12:04 am Post subject:

Rob's face is the only one I see when I re-read Twilight.... if it were about trying to find someone who was the complete embodiment of Edward, the movie just couldn't even be made. But I think Rob is going to absolutely emmerse himself in the role and he is going to do it so well. I'm not worried at all! Wink

**urmylifenow17** · Posted: Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:53 am Post subject:

I could have already mentioned this but I'll say it again...Reading HP than watching the film adaption taught me a hard lesson about separating the two. I would be so hurt when they would miss critical parts from the movie and all that. Its a hard thing to do but hey. So I'm going to go to this movie with an open mind, but seeing all the clips from TW I can honestly say that it looks pretty darn close to the books.

_________________

http://twilightmomsforums.freeforums.org/petition-up-please-sign-sm-to-go-on-oprah-t6624.html

**ash.i.am** · Posted: Fri Jun 06, 2008 4:59 am Post subject:

Movies will never be as good as books. We have our imaginations with those! Nothing beats that.

_________________
~Ash
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world."

**Bella** · Topaz Vampire Joined: 22 Jan 2008 Posts: 4567

You're right; movies are never as good as the books they came from. I am going to try to keep an open mind though and try to overlook the things the movie skips, or combines into one scene, or changes the location of from the book, etc. I've already seen a couple of these things just from the clips so I won't let myself get upset. I'll just go to enjoy looking at my Edward -- Robert is so beautiful!

_________________

"I had an adrenaline rush. It's very common -- you can Google it."

**trejakesmom** · Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 2:55 am Post subject:

i just hope they dont mutilate it like the people who made eragon. i like those books and when i went to see the movie it was horrible. from what i have seen online twilight looks to at least follow the story. i am keeping my fingers crossed. i know they cant keep everything the same. just as long as all the major things are still in it it should be good.

**DebraAnn** · Posted: Tue Jun 17, 2008 11:14 am Post subject:

The only worry I have is for the people that judge the film, when they haven't had the experience of the books. Otherwise I have no concerns at all. I am relieved that computer generation will not take over this film. Unlike with Harry Potter, it worked so well and blended in nicely. Twilight doesn't need all that hocus pocus... My attention is on the character development, just like the books.

_________________
"I think I'm fairly smitten with Rob." - Me

pinkpygmypuff · Newborn Joined: 03 Apr 2008 Posts: 11

I was very happy with the movie and the characters that we were seeing in all the tidbits we were seeing, until now! The Field trip scene when Edward was telling Bella about stopping the car, and he told her to Google it! Something about that just ran right thru me. I panicked; did anyone else feel that way? If this has already been talked about please forgive, I did try to read everything before posting…felt like I need to make a disclaimer

**amanda31** · Posted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 3:59 am Post subject:

I'd be lying if I didn't say I was worried the movie would be bad, but I'm keeping my hopes up that it's as amazing as well all know it can me. I think they did a great job with casting, so that's a plus. And the clips we've seen so far have been pretty good. I am a little nervous about the new scenes they added, but hopefully it all flows together well and doesn't take away anything from those of us who read the book. Because I know when I watch the Harry Potter movies, I spend half of my time being distracted by the changes (information omitted, scenes added, story line changes, etc).

_________________
Join us for a DC/MD/NoVa meet up!

**amanda31** · Posted: Tue Jun 24, 2008 4:01 am Post subject: Re: Google it!

pinkpygmypuff wrote:

I was very happy with the movie and the characters that we were seeing in all the tidbits we were seeing, until now! The Field trip scene when Edward was telling Bella about stopping the car, and he told her to Google it! Something about that just ran right thru me. I panicked; did anyone else feel that way? If this has already been talked about please forgive, I did try to read everything before posting…felt like I need to make a disclaimer

I can understand. If Edward said "google" in the book, I'd find it completely out of place! But for some reason I don't mind Edward saying it in the movie...Rob can get away with it Very Happy

_________________
Join us for a DC/MD/NoVa meet up!

**ILoveEdward** · Posted: Wed Jun 25, 2008 4:17 am Post subject:

I'm re-reading Twilight and I would say that half of the time I don't imagine Robert as Edward. I think it's the way Stephenie describes the scenes. I think everyone forms their own vision or feeling of what Edward looks like. However, I think Robert will do a great job. I can't wait to see how it all goes down.

_________________
Lisa from Ohio

paperback.pixie · Newborn Joined: 20 Jun 2008 Posts: 41

DebraAnn wrote:

The only worry I have is for the people that judge the film, when they haven't had the experience of the books.

I feel the same way! Although, I am trying to use the movie to get my friend to read the books. I sent her a link to the trailer--she's a big Harry Potter fan, so I really played up Rob being in it and how very dreamy he looks...Her reply was that the trailer looked cool (this is probably her attempt at being nice, for my sake) and that Rob looked creepy and had weird hair. Surprised

I sucked in a breath at that! I think she'd feel VERY differently if she'd give in already and just read the books!!

_________________

pretty icons by Laura and Jessica

**Bittersweet** · Posted: Fri Jul 04, 2008 7:18 am Post subject:

I'm pretty sure the movie is going to suck (in my mind/opinoin of course)..and nothing against the actors, I just hate how "they" change things from the book to movie. Sometimes its big changes but even the small changes just bug me. Even from what I've seen online of the movie, nothing fits exactly into what was written. I know the argument is made that it can't be just like the book and...well I don't buy that Smile

And again I don't mean like Laurent being black or Carlisle/Esme being older then the book, etc etc..I mean actual storyline..

Oh I'll still go to see it for sure. Hopefully the first showing around here if I can help it.

**missaloo** · Posted: Wed Jul 09, 2008 5:37 am Post subject:

I'm a little worried about how they'll make Edward sparkle...

_________________

avatar made by emaleth! Very Happy

**BamaTwilighter** · Posted: Wed Jul 09, 2008 11:53 pm Post subject:

Oh, it won't be nearly as good, but I will still love it. We all keep referencing back to Harry Potter because it is a prime example of how the movie industry has, in my mind, ruined something that was so perfect in book form. I want to see these books so bad on film but I already can see myself sitting in the theater like I have done with all the HP's screaming (at least in my head) at the screen, "Wait, that isn't right! That is not how she wrote it!"

I know that it can't be the same and after 5 ok Harry Potter adaptations and 2 "I could have done without" Nicholas Sparks adapts, I will be happy with "Twilight" just because it is "Twilight."

Casting wise, I am pretty happy. I am still torn on Jacob because I have something completely different in my mind, especially when when I get to "New Moon" and "Eclipse."

I will be there, December 12, waiting in line with the rest of you. Smile

_________________

http://groups.myspace.com/twilighterssupportsm